Well, if you spent any time at home yesterday, you probably saw some of the Roger Clemens hearing.
I really think at this point Clemens has convinced himself he is telling the truth, which obviously isn't good enough. There are several factors that help him: Clemens hasn't exhibited the cartoonish transformation that a lot of other steroid and HGH users have. Also, his numbers at age 40+ did not eclipse the numbers he put up in his twenties; they were just very good. Unlike Bonds, Clemens didn't set a new plateau for himself as he got older, he just remained consistent. He also hasn't shied away from the public, and has flatly denied all allegations on national television and under oath.
That said, there is a lot that favors McNamee. A lot of the congressmen tried to get McNamee to admit he had lied in the past about steroids, to which he admitted he had. But in those cases, he had every reason to lie; here, he gains nothing by lying. Clemens, meanwhile, has a reason to lie, and so that definitely points the needle in McNamee's favor.
On top of that, Andy Pettitte and his wife testified against Clemens. Pettitte said that he had a conversation with Roger back in 1999 or 2000 about using HGH.
Put all of that together with the inconsistencies and contradictions in Clemens' arguments and you've got a one-sided battle here. Other than Clemens' word, we have no substance to believe that he is telling the truth. Meanwhile, there are sworn testimonies and possible DNA evidence that leads us to believe McNamee.
McNamee isn't exactly the best guy in the world, but this all points to him telling the truth.
The hearing in itself was really a joke, i.e. Republican Dan Burton saying to McNamee, "This is really disgusting. You're here as a sworn witness, you're here to tell the truth, you're here under oath. And yet we have lie, after lie, after lie...I don't know what to believe. I know one thing I don't believe, and that's you...Roger Clemens...is a titan in baseball."
Republican Virgina Foxx then held up pictures of Clemens and deduced that there was no physical difference over his career. What is this, some kind of joke?
And the best quote of the day had to come from Democrat Eleanor Holmes Norton, who proclaimed: "Mr. Clemens, all I can say is, I'm sure you're going to heaven."
To the average eye, Clemens might seem like he's telling the truth. Clemens played himself off as a hard-working, determined man who spends his free time with kids. McNamee is a corrupt ex-cop. Even so, McNamee gained more credibility yesterday.
As for me, I want Clemens to be telling the truth. But you can't always get what you want.
When the hearings closed, no verdict was given and no questions were answered. The biggest new information that came out of the hearings was that Andy Pettitte had also taken HGH in 2004. But referring to Roger Clemens and Brian McNamee, no questions were answered. In fact, more questions were probably raised. Ultimately, while a lot of the evidence points against Clemens, our government was unsuccessful in giving a definitive answer on who is telling the truth and who is lying.
If you're wondering why our government accomplishes so little, the Roger Clemens congressional hearing has answered your question.